A new 10-year retrospective study of gender-dysphoric patients 18 and over concludes that transgender surgeries increase the risk of mental health issues. This study was published in the Journal of Sexual Medicine and is the largest sample size of any study on the topic.

The study results state, “From 107 583 patients, matched cohorts demonstrated that those undergoing surgery were at significantly higher risk for depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, and substance use disorders than those without surgery.”

Male adults with gender dysphoria who received surgery had depression rates of 25%, while those who didn’t receive surgery had a depression rate of 11.5%. 12.8% of males with surgery had anxiety compared to 2.6% of those who didn’t receive surgery. 22.95% of females with surgery had depression compared to 14.6% of those without surgery. The anxiety rates were 10.5% for the surgery group and 7.1% without surgery.

The authors said the results are more reliable based on the methodology, although the non-randomized sample means they could not adjust for confounding factors, including social support. The authors state, “By leveraging ICD-10 codes, we provide a more accurate representation of patient demographics and clinical outcomes, minimizing recall and reporting biases that often limit survey-based research.”

The strongest study that shows improved mental health outcomes from transgender surgeries for those with gender dysphoria relied on surveys filled out by the patients and was published in 2021. A 2011 study concluded that self-reported data is unreliable due to biases. The authors wrote, “These findings support the hypothesis that social desirability and recall bias are likely to affect the self-reported use of mental health services in a population survey… Roughly 75% of those recorded as users of mental health services users in the RAMQ’s register did not report using mental health services in the CCHS-1.2.”

The latest study with a more reliable methodology shows worsening mental health outcomes across the board for individuals who move forward with transgender surgery. The authors concluded, “Gender-affirming surgery, while beneficial in affirming gender identity, is associated with increased risk of mental health issues, underscoring the need for ongoing, gender-sensitive mental health support for transgender individuals’ post-surgery.”

Despite the results showing worse mental health outcomes after transgender surgeries, the authors state that the surgery is “beneficial in affirming gender identity” and shows the need for ongoing mental health support.

Eithan Haim, a Texas Children’s Hospital whistleblower, accused the authors of “ignoring the most obvious cause of declining mental health.” Haim appeared on The HighWire to discuss the case that was brought against him for releasing information to journalist Christopher Rufo about the hospital continuing to provide “gender-affirming care” despite the claim that they stopped providing that type of medical care.

In 2022, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton issued a formal opinion calling “so-called sex change procedures” on children and the prescription of puberty blockers child abuse. After Haim provided information to Rufo, the DOJ brought charges against Haim, which have since been dropped under the new administration.

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) provides guidelines for treating individuals with gender dysphoria, which is considered a mental health disorder, and individuals with “gender incongruence” which is not considered a mental health disorder. Both of these conditions can be treated with “various gender-affirming treatment options,” according to WPATH.

The WPATH SOC-8 provides a long list of “medically necessary gender-affirming care interventions.” It states, “These include but are not limited to hysterectomy +/- bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy; bilateral mastectomy, chest reconstruction or feminizing mammoplasty, nipple resizing or placement of breast prostheses; genital reconstruction, for example, phalloplasty and metoidioplasty, scrotoplasty, and penile and testicular prostheses, penectomy, orchiectomy, vaginoplasty, and vulvoplasty; hair removal from the face, body, and genital areas for gender affirmation or as part of a preoperative preparation process; gender-affirming facial surgery and body contouring; voice therapy and/or surgery; as well as puberty-blocking medication and gender-affirming hormones; counseling or psychotherapeutic treatment as appropriate for the patient and based on a review of the patient’s individual circumstances and needs.”

WPATH adds, “WPATH urges health care systems to provide these medically necessary treatments and eliminate any exclusions from their policy documents and medical guidelines that preclude coverage for any medically necessary procedures or treatments for the health and well-being of TGD individuals.”

The HighWire reported last July about WPATH’s move to remove age minimums from its recommendations after receiving pressure from Admiral Rachel Levine, the assistant secretary for health at the Department of Health and Human Services in the Biden administration. WPATH made this adjustment despite concerns about “sloppy” assessments and “opportunism by inexperienced and sometimes dangerous providers.”

Chloe Cole, a female detransitioner, shared the study and confirmed that receiving a double mastectomy as a child did not improve her mental health.

The HighWire has reported multiple lawsuits against care providers for failure to provide informed consent and misdiagnosis of gender dysphoria. Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy, a well-known transgender care provider, is the defendant in one of those lawsuits. She was also the lead author of a study that did not show any change in mental health outcomes for children who received puberty blockers. Dr. Olson-Kennedy refused to release the study, fearing that the results would be weaponized.

Haim called the latest study a “bombshell” and said the authors have published other papers with “pseudo-intellectual jargon.” Haim wrote on X, “They never question the validity of the surgeries – only that mental health support is needed AFTER surgery. They accept the surgeries as self-evidently beneficial since they “affirm gender identity.” He added, “They explicitly endorse the transgender party line yet undercut its central premise that they improve mental health outcomes.

Steven Middendorp

Steven Middendorp is an investigative journalist, musician, and teacher. He has been a freelance writer and journalist for over 20 years. More recently, he has focused on issues dealing with corruption and negligence in the judicial system. He is a homesteading hobby farmer who encourages people to grow their own food, eat locally, and care for the land that provides sustenance to the community.

Other Headlines

Coronavirus

ICAN Releases Recordings of FDA’s Peter Marks; Vaccine Official Dismissed Vaccine Injuries

The Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN) and REACT 19 held a joint press conference today to reveal a trove of secret recordings and FOIA documents of Peter Marks, the former Director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research. The press conference included ICAN Founder Del Bigtree, Attorney Aaron Siri, and REACT 19’s Brianne Dressen.Continue reading ICAN Releases Recordings of FDA’s Peter Marks; Vaccine Official Dismissed Vaccine Injuries

More news about Coronavirus

Health & Nutrition

New Fluoride Study Ignores Neurotoxicity and Sugar Intake in Cost Analysis

A new fluoride study has been criticized for being a tool of the industry to promote continued water fluoridation following the banning of the practice in Utah and Florida. The authors conducted a simulation model and cost-effectiveness analysis with data from 8484 children with a mean age of 9.6 years. The authors concluded eliminating fluorideContinue reading New Fluoride Study Ignores Neurotoxicity and Sugar Intake in Cost Analysis

More news about Health & Nutrition

Vaccines

HHS Terminates Moderna Contract For Bird Flu Vaccine; Calls mRNA Technology “Under-Tested”

HHS has terminated a $766 million contract with Moderna to develop an mRNA bird flu vaccine. HHS spokesman Andrew Nixon said the decision is about “safety, integrity, and trust.” He added that “mRNA technology remains under-tested, and we are not going to spend taxpayer dollars repeating the mistakes of the last administration, which concealed legitimateContinue reading HHS Terminates Moderna Contract For Bird Flu Vaccine; Calls mRNA Technology “Under-Tested”

More news about Vaccines

Science & Tech

Humanoid Robots Malfunction and Attack; Sparks Debate Over AI Safety and Liability

A viral video released from an undisclosed Chinese factory shows a humanoid robot malfunctioning and attacking the factory workers. The Unitree H1, a product of the Chinese company Unitree Robotics, can be seen flailing its arms as workers move away to protect themselves. The robot was hung on a crane, and the workers were notContinue reading Humanoid Robots Malfunction and Attack; Sparks Debate Over AI Safety and Liability

More news about Science & Tech

Environment

CDC Advised Health Care Providers Not to Test East Palestine Residents for Chemical Illnesses, Lawsuit Alleges

Newsnation reported this week that the CDC advised local health care providers in East Palestine, OH, not to test local residents for chemical illnesses after the town was exposed to a toxic plume from a “controlled burn” after the Norfolk Southern train derailment in 2023. A lawsuit has been filed against Norfolk Southern and moreContinue reading CDC Advised Health Care Providers Not to Test East Palestine Residents for Chemical Illnesses, Lawsuit Alleges

More news about Environment

Policy

HHS and CMS Urge Changes to Gender-Affirming Care for Minors; Clinics Face Potential Loss of Federal Funding

HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. wrote a letter addressed to healthcare providers saying he expects them to update their “treatment protocols and training to ensure that care for children with gender dysphoria is evidence-based.” The letter was also addressed to healthcare risk managers and state medical boards. The letter refers to the report publishedContinue reading HHS and CMS Urge Changes to Gender-Affirming Care for Minors; Clinics Face Potential Loss of Federal Funding

More news about Policy